Latest Laois News: Portlaoise begging dispute rumbles on

Latest Laois News: Portlaoise begging dispute rumbles on

Dear Editor,

Thursday the 13th April will be remembered in Portlaoise as the day the Joint Policing Committee declared out-right war on the poor of that town.

I seem to be writing a lot of critique about Sinn Féin lately.

At heart I am a republican. In the tradition of James Connolly I long for a 32 county socialist republic. A society with a place for all its people, not just the chosen few.

I know and like a lot of Sinn Féin members in Laois. They were very helpful during the 2020 election campaign when People Before Profit in the Laois/Offaly constituency and Sinn Fein seemed to be working together to break the cycle of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. There are a lot of good people in that organisation who I respect and hope they don’t take my critiques personally.

Sinn Féin, as a political party, seem to be drifting more and more to the right, away from the socialist principles which they claim to champion.

This was made evident again recently by an article in the local paper (link here) where it was reported that gardaí and a community led group was established to tackle aggressive begging and anti-social behaviour in Portlaoise.

This group has an Orwellian sounding title – The Joint Policing Committee.

I was very surprised to find that this attack on the poorest of the poor is being led by Sinn Féin councillor Caroline Dwane Stanley who brought the issue of aggressive begging in Portlaoise to the fore last December.

It seems Sinn Fein are now supporting some kind of local militia army determined to clean the streets of the poor.

Begging is a very basic form of speech. Being able to ask your fellow human beings for help when you’re in a desperate situation could save your life. It deserves to be protected as much as any form of speech.

Campaigns against begging are not about protecting the public. They are not about anti-social behaviour. They are about social cleansing. They are about cleaning up the streets to hide the reality of poverty. It’s so rich people don’t have to feel uncomfortable each time they are faced with the results of their greed on the street.

Stephen Tynan

Human rights campaigners argue that towns, by using these kinds of draconian measures, are criminalising people rather than addressing the reasons that force them to beg in the first place.

There is a lot of talk about so-called professional beggars who drive BMWs. No one had actually seen them and several TV documentary teams who tried to prove it found no evidence of their existence. Rosie Brighouse, legal officer at the human rights charity Liberty says that most of the evidence on the circumstances of people who beg is anecdotal, and that the issue requires more thorough research

She said that –

“Some people seem to think they should have a right not to be approached by people on the street. But others who think a public space is a public space believe people should be able to approach each other for help. It’s hard to avoid the conclusion that campaigns against begging are about social cleansing and cleaning up streets, just so they look better.”

Stephen Tynan


In response Councillor Caroline Dwane Stanley had this to say:

Dear Editor,

I note that a person from another political party has chosen to deliberately misrepresent an issue I raised in November at the Joint Policing Committee (JPC )Meeting .

See letter criticising cllr Caroline Dwane Stanley above.

This followed on from complaints from elderly people in Portlaoise of money being aggressively demanded and the intimidation of them. I witnessed incidents of this myself .

Councillor Caroline Dwane Stanley

I made absolutely clear at the meeting that I don’t have an issue with people begging. I have also made this clear in statements since , but what I witnessed myself was pure intimidation.

My position continues to be that everybody has rights including old age pensioners going about their normal business.

Indeed I work with people for over the past 20 years on a daily basis from disadvantaged areas including those who are on the lowest of incomes.

The sub group of the Joint Policing Committee that is being set up is to deal with criminal and antisocial activity and to liaise with people in the local community to improve our town .

The author of the letter needs to explain why he feels it’s acceptable to intimidate our elderly and vulnerable people in our community. This is a simple case of political opportunism.

Councillor Caroline Dwane Stanley

Statement from Stephen Tynan in response:

I challenge Councillor Dwane Stanley to point out to the readers where in my letter I said it was “acceptable to intimidate our elderly. “Caroline accuses me of misrepresenting issues by making false claims herself. In fact if she can prove that I ever even suggested such an outrageous thing I will resign form People Before Profit.

Perhaps Councillor Dwane Stanley would also explain to the readers why she is addressing me in such a derogatory fashion. I believe it is common courtesy to address the person you are speaking to by name? It’s not as though Councillor Dwane Stanley and I have never met.

A further statement from Stephen Tynan (pictured here) on begging dispute

I am still of the opinion that campaigns against begging are an attack on the poorest of the poor. I suggest that people read the original article published in Laois Today and judge for themselves if Caroline is on the side of the beggars or the Status quo. I don’t want to risk been accused again of twisting her words

Please note Laois People made contact with Cllr. Dwane Stanley re additional response from Stephen Tynan above. There will be no further statement from Cllr. Dwane Stanley on this particular issue.